At Wine Enthusiast, our tasting panel’s job is relatively straightforward: judge and rate wines blind based purely on quality, with no inkling of producer or price. But at the end of the day when choosing what we’ll pour at the dinner table, we’re like any other wine lover in these tough economic times: price matters, and we’re as thrilled for ourselves as for our readers when we find an outstanding Cabernet for $15, or a knockout Sauvignon Blanc that won’t break the bank.
That’s why we’re pleased to share with our readers the discoveries we find as reviewers: when the bags that disguise reviewed wines’ identities come off and the scores are in, we then determine whether the wine can be given the Best Buy status, i.e. if a wine’s score on the Wine Enthusiast 100-point scale is high in relation to its price (a very precise formula we keep to ourselves, but 87-points-and-above and $15-and-below are approximate yardsticks). The higher the rating and lower the price, the more of a quintessential Best Buy a wine becomes—no mystery about that.
Only about 10% of the 10,000 wines we review annually merit this designation. So enjoy this elite grouping of Best Buy wines. In selecting, opening and sharing with friends and family, you won’t be disappointed.
Reviews and accompanying text are by Lauren Buzzeo, Joe Czerwinski, Paul Gregutt, Steve Heimoff, Susan Kostrzewa, Monica Larner, Michael Schachner and Roger Voss.
To see the article with our top 100 Best Buys of 2009, click here.