For fans of Russian River Valley Pinot Noir, three recent vintages (’07, ’08 and ’09) have been treasure troves. Although each vintage presented challenges, vintners finessed them. Collectively, these years add up to the greatest series of harvests in California Pinot’s history.
There are several reasons for this: Vines planted in the early 2000s started to mature, vintners fine-tuned their techniques and Sideways helped—as demand for Pinot Noir rose, so did prices, giving winemakers the means to invest. Another important factor was that all three years were relatively cool.
The result has been Pinot Noirs of unprecedented purity and transparency. That’s great news for wine lovers, and the icing on the cake is that these balanced wines allow the Russian River Valley’s multiple terroirs to shine through—terroirs, plural, being the operative term. The valley is so vast and diverse that the wines exhibit subtle differences. For Pinotphiles with discerning palates, knowing these differences can help them zero in on the wines that are most likely to offer deep enjoyment.
Climate drives the differences
The Russian River Valley is a huge appellation, sprawling over 126,000 acres. As anyone who’s ever explored it on a summer day knows, one minute you can have the headlights on in a misty redwood grove, and the next, you’re reaching for the sunglasses and air conditioning as the sun beats down. The average July high temperature in Occidental, at the far southwestern edge of the appellation, is 11 degrees lower than in Healdsburg, 20 miles northeast.
Yet winemakers, who have to sell their products to a public already saturated with appellations, are reluctant to ask consumers to accept even more. “After much work [by the Russian River Valley Winegrowers Association], we seem to have established the quality and character of Russian River wines in the consumers’ minds,” says Adam Lee, the proprietor (with his wife, Dianna) of Siduri Wines. “Making changes now would seem to be premature at best and confusing at worst.”
Thinking clearly about fog
The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) of the Treasury Department, which is in charge of approving AVAs, does so on the basis of “climate, soils, elevation and physical features.” What distinguishes the Russian River Valley, in particular, was defined by the TTB in 1983, when it established the appellation’s original boundary lines, asserting that “Fog is the single most unifying and significant feature of the…Russian River Valley.”
Yet, the fog isn’t a factor everywhere. Its impact, or lack thereof, depends on how far away the vineyard is from water—not just the Russian River itself, but the Pacific Ocean to the west and San Pablo Bay to the south. And topography plays a role. The valley is studded with peaks rising to nearly 2,000 feet. This creates conduits through which cold maritime air, including fog, can penetrate miles inland. Elevation plays a significant role, too. The highest ridge tops are often above the fog, allowing slow-ripening varieties like Zinfandel to thrive, where thin-skinned Pinot Noir grapes would overripen.
From the earth to the bottle
There’s broad agreement that the Russian River Valley can be divided into three areas, based on a temperature–fog spectrum: the Middle Reach, the Santa Rosa Plain and Green Valley. This is essentially a warm-cool-cooler template.
The Middle Reach, being inland, is the warmest part of the valley; there are even scattered plantings of Cabernet Sauvignon, and Dry Creek Valley is just a stone’s throw away. Middle Reach Pinot Noirs are rich, full-bodied,ripe and soft. At their best, as in Williams Selyem’s Estate bottling, they are the Russian River’s most opulent Pinot Noirs, feminine and dazzling in voluptuous charm. They are wines to drink young, although the best age well.
If there’s a downside, it’s that the Middle Reach, especially as it approaches Healdsburg, flirts with overripeness, a tendency that can be aggravated in a hot year, or even by a single heat spike.
The Santa Rosa Plain, by contrast, is a low-lying area east of the city of Santa Rosa, stretching west to where a series of hills, the Laguna Ridges, announce the Coast Ranges. Frost-prone in spring, it’s influenced by cool winds that sweep up from the Petaluma Gap to the south. A quintessential Santa Rosa Plain Pinot Noir is Joseph Swan’s Trenton Estate. It’s tangier, earthier and more mushroomy than almost anything from the Middle Reach, with harderedged tannins and firmer acidity. These are dry, elegant wines; they can be tight, even austere, in youth. But they brim with berries, and are wines to lay down.
The Green Valley (which has been an AVA within Russian River Valley since 1983) is the area’s icebox, at least at the lower elevations where most of the Pinot grows. Green Valley gets a direct hit from the prevailing winds that sweep in off the Pacific and Bodega Bay, where the waters seldom rise to 60°F.
Classic Pinot Noirs from the Russian River Valley’s main subregions
98 Williams Selyem 2008 Litton Estate Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $100.
This is the best of the winery’s new releases, both for drinking now and for cellaring. Combines power and elegance, with upscale flavors of cherry, currant, cola, rhubarb, dried herbs and oak, wrapped into devastatingly rich tannins and a perfect touch of acidity. Should age well for 10 years. Cellar Selection.
93 J Vineyards & Winery 2008 Nicole’s Vineyard Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $50.
Here’s a luscious, delicious Pinot Noir for drinking now. It’s made in the modern style of soft ripeness, and features upfront cherry, cranberry, sweet fig and sandalwood flavors, with a tangy dusting of Indian spices. The acidity and tannins are near perfect. Drink now–2016.
88 Tudal 2009 Bacigalupi Vineyard Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $50.
The vineyard is in a warmer part of the valley, and the wine is a bit rustic, lacking some delicacy. But it has deeply delicious raspberry and cherry pie-filling flavors, with earth and licorice notes elaborated by smoky oak. Give it a good, long decant.Santa Rosa Plain
Santa Rosa Plain
97 Joseph Swan 2007 Trenton Estate Vineyard Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $52.
An awesome Pinot Noir—it’s hard to find words to describe its beauty. It’s bone dry and rich in stimulating acidity, and the cherry and raspberry fruit flavors have an earthy, mushroomy quality that grounds the wine and gives it a real sense of terroir. Shows the fleshy attractions of the amazing ’07 vintage, with an undisputed capacity to age. Now–2017, at least. Editors’ Choice.
94 Fog Crest 2008 Estate Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $45.
A marvelous Pinot Noir to drink now and over the next 6–7 years. It feels so rich and elaborate, with waves of raspberries, cherries, cola and oak, yet is tightly controlled by firm tannins and a great burst of citrusy acidity. Grows better and better as it warms in the glass.
96 Merry Edwards 2008 Klopp Ranch Méthode à L’Ancienne Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $57.
So delicious and complex now in wild cherry, raspberry, Dr. Pepper cola, bacon and smoky sandalwood flavors, brightened with crisp acidity and totally dry despite the fruitiness. But you’ll also find a firm tannic structure that gives it some astringency. Drinkable now for sheer beauty but easily capable of aging for a decade.
96 Freeman 2008 Keefer Ranch Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $47.
So pale in color, it’s hard to believe it packs so much flavor. Stuns with the complexity of its cherries, raspberries and cola, with fantastically spicy notes. Hard to describe just how intricate it feels, changing by the second as the palate uncovers additional nuances. A great Pinot Noir, defining silkiness and delicacy, and should age effortlessly for at least the next six years.
95 Marimar Estate 2007 Don Miguel Vineyard Cristina Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley); $49.
Massive, flamboyantly rich, a real treasure in the mouth. Just dazzles with the intensity of cherries, black raspberries, Dr. Pepper cola, plums, sweet vanilla- scented sandalwood and a wild array of savory spices. The wine is a small-production barrel selection from the estate vineyard, which is in the heart of the Green Valley. Drink now and through 2013, at least.
94 Dutton Goldfield 2009 Dutton Ranch Emerald Ranch Pinot Noir (Green Valley); $58.
An extraordinarily beautiful Pinot Noir, dry, silky and just captivating. With profoundly ripe cherry and mulberry fruit, it shows earthy complexities, spices and flowers, and the oak overlay is just about perfect. A gorgeous wine that should age for six years.