Canadian Whisky Reimagined and Redefined

Canada wasn't always known for whisky, but distillers are changing that notion and producing some of the best bottles in the world.
From left to right; Collingwood, Lot No. 40 Canadian Rye Whisky, Crown Royal Blenders’ Mash and Canadian Club 100% Rye / Photo by Jens Johnson

A visit to the blending lab for Crown Royal, Canada’s best-known whisky maker, uncovers a spirits lover’s dream office. Pristine filing cabinets slide open to reveal row upon row of meticulously organized flasks.

Inside the drawers, whiskies in every conceivable shade are lined up like the ultimate box of crayons, from crystal-clear, unaged distillate to deep, dark amber developed through years of barrel rest. The various ages, grain combinations and flavors of whisky are all represented.

In many ways, these cabinets are a metaphor for Canadian whisky itself. Once considered mellow and monotone, producers have transformed the category into a riotous rainbow of bold, interesting bottlings.

Whisky or Whiskey?

Americans spell whiskey with an “e,” but just like their counterparts in Scotland, Canadians typically spell it “whisky.”

Whether it’s Crown Royal’s Northern Harvest Rye, a lean, peppery whisky made with 90% rye and named 2016’s World Whisky of the Year in Jim Murray’s annual Whisky Bible or, on the other end of the spectrum, comforting, caramel-forward bottlings like Caribou Crossing, Canadian whisky is ringing up sales for good reason.

According to the Distilled Spirits Council of the United States, sales of Canadian whisky in the U.S. rose 7% between 2011 and 2016, with a 112% spike in the high-end premium category.

“The whisky world is waking up to Canadian whisky and declaring it among the best whiskies in the world,” says Davin de Kergommeaux in the second edition of his book, Canadian Whisky. Bars and restaurants in the U.S. are also adding Canadian bottlings to spirits lists.

“It is again cool to be seen sipping Canadian.”

It’s Not Bourbon

While Canada’s whisky history parallels that of America, the two would diverge. It’s why there are differences in how whisky is made and how it tastes across the border.

The stories began similarly. Settlers from Europe arrived in North America with knowledge of traditional distilling techniques, which they applied to the abundant grains—corn, wheat, barley and rye—they discovered in the new world.

While corn, required to make Bourbon, was long the dominant ingredient in American whiskey, rye became the key player in Canada’s whisky history. Favored by Dutch and German immigrants, the hardy grain thrived in the cooler northern climate. America grew and distilled the grain as well, but in Canada, rye-based whisky was so prevalent that for decades, all Canadian­ whisky was referred to simply as “rye.” Its spicy character is considered a signature of Canadian bottlings.

How Wine Affects Your Whiskey

But agriculture and consumer tastes evolved. Corn is now the most commonly used grain in Canadian whisky, except for a handful of rye-focused bottlings.

The Prohibition years provided another point of divergence. While American liquor was forced underground and into private homes and clubs during the 1920s, Canada continued its whisky- making traditions. De Kergommeaux­ estimates that during those years, Canadian whisky made up about 10% of alcoholic beverages consumed in the U.S.

By the time Prohibition ended in 1933, many of America’s distillers had long abandoned their craft. In many cases, a new generation of producers started over with different processes, recipes and equipment. Canadian counter­parts, meanwhile, enjoyed more continuity in production.

Although Canadian whisky thrived in the 1950s through ’70s, consumer tastes for white spirits, particularly vodka, eroded sales over the following two decades. Canadian distilleries consolidated, and many closed.

Eight large conglomerates remained by the 2000s, and Canadian whisky was considered­ something your grandfather drank. Don Draper quaffed Canadian Club on Mad Men. Yet, a whisky revolution was brewing.

Northern Re-exposure

“Canadian whisky is starting to wake up a little bit,” says Dr. Don Livermore, master blender at Hiram Walker & Sons Limited/Pernod Ricard Canada. He’s responsible for whisky brands that include Lot 40, JP Wiser’s and Pike Creek.

Livermore refers to the industry’s response to the increased demand for whisky across all categories. It started as a groundswell for Bourbon and Scotch, and it has expanded to countries like Japan and Ireland as curious whisky drinkers embrace a wider range of world whiskies.

Until recently, Canada’s whisky attracted limited attention. It was often viewed as light and traditional. In other words, it was largely forgettable.

Over the past decade, however, Canadian distillers have been building memorable drams. These new stylings showcase the range and potential behind the category.

“Canadian whisky is the most innovative, creative and adaptable style whisky there is,” says Livermore. Compared to Scotch or Bourbon, two styles laden with regulations that can hamper experimentation,­ Canada’s whisky makers have a fairly broad mandate.

Canadian Whisky Defined

What makes Canadian whisky? The rules are pretty straightforward. It must be:

• Made from grain

• Fermented, aged and distilled in Canada

• Aged a minimum of three years

• Aged in “small wood,” which means a barrel no larger than 700 liters

“All we have to do is be made of grain; fermented, aged and distilled in Canada; and aged in a wooden barrel less than 700 liters for a minimum of three years,” says Livermore. “That’s it.”

That means the door is wide open for Canada’s distillers to innovate. They can work with a wide range of barrel types or finishes, any combination of grains or any distillation method. It’s not a problem to add a measure of oloroso Sherry to the mix, which contributes intriguing dark, earthy notes to Alberta Rye Dark Batch Whisky. And while Scotland requires oak barrels to make Scotch, there’s nothing to stop Canada from using maple wood, part of the aging process for brown sugar–tinged Collingwood.

“Canadian whisky is in a position to adapt to what consumers are looking for,” says Livermore. “We’re not stuck.”

He says that consumers, younger ones in particular, seek bigger, bolder flavors like spicy rye, as well as high-end premium bottlings.

Much like the craft beer movement, a growing number of small distilleries bring new energy and bold flavors to the Canadian whisky scene. At tiny Cirka Distilleries in Montreal, one of Canada’s 40-plus micro-distilleries (by comparison, the U.S. has hundreds), for instance, whiskies made with local grain are only halfway through their mandated three-year aging time. Yet, a 100% rye whisky pulled directly from the barrel already snaps with notes of chocolate and cherry.

Come on in, the Whisky’s Fine

Canada is also doubling down on education to familiarize consumers with the country’s native spirit.

John Hall of Forty Creek Distillery, now owned by Gruppo Campari, helped rebuild Canada’s reputation in terms of both openness and quality. When Hall, a winemaking veteran, started the operation in 1992, he noticed that the country offered few small-batch whiskies, especially when compared to the variety of selections from Scotland or the U.S.

Hall is now retired from the whisky business, but small-batch bottlings abound, a tribute to his legacy.

Another sign of the times: After years of near-secrecy, distilleries now welcome consumers with visitor centers and tasting rooms. In addition to many micro-distilleries that offer tours and tastes, Hiram Walker now features a “J.P. Wiser’s Experience” in its Ontario distillery.

8 Easy Steps to Blend Your Own Whiskey

Sazerac, too, has plans to soon welcome visitors to its Old Montreal Distillery, just a short walk across the bridge from historic Old Montreal. Whisky hadn’t been made on-site in decades, but that changed in January when production resumed thanks to a newly installed 37-foot copper still.

Long term, Sazerac’s plan is not to just make Canadian­ whisky, but to innovate with a wide range of single-barrel and small-batch experiments. The company has plenty of bona fides when it comes to this endeavor. Harlen Wheatley, the master distiller at Buffalo Trace known for producing groundbreaking Bourbons in his experimental warehouse in Kentucky, is consulting on the project.

If in the past, Canadian whisky was derided as boring, or in Hall’s words, “same old, same old,” these whiskies will surely be anything but. “What Buffalo Trace did for Bourbon, we want to do for Canadian whisky,” says Gerry Cristiano, plant manager for Sazerac’s Canadian whisky operations.

He motions to a lineup of barrels, already filled with distillate, at the far end of a mostly empty warehouse.

“Thirty years from now, we’ll look back at this as the beginning.”

From left to right; Crown Royal Northern Harvest Rye, Caribou Crossing Single Barrel and Alberta Rye Dark Batch Whisky
From left to right; Crown Royal Northern Harvest Rye, Caribou Crossing Single Barrel and Alberta Rye Dark Batch Whisky / Photo by Jens Johnson

Lot No. 40 Canadian Rye Whisky; $40, 97 points. This full-bodied blended whisky hits all the right notes, starting with plenty of rich caramel and oak tones on the nose and palate, plus touches of butterscotch, spicy cinnamon and clove. It finishes long, slightly oily and mouthfilling. Sip it straight or add a splash of sweet vermouth. abv: 43%

Crown Royal Blenders’ Mash; $28, 95 points. This is one of five whiskies that make up the Crown Royal signature blend. The complex aroma combines vanilla, maple and a hint of espresso. The big, bold, buttery palate echoes those flavors, finishing with a flurry of spice. Limited edition. Best Buy. abv: 40% 

Canadian Club 100% Rye; $20, 94 points. You don’t see many 100% rye whiskies, and even fewer this easy-sipping. Look for vanilla and oak layered with hints of apricot and golden raisin, plus an elongated, drying finish sprinkled with plenty of baking spice. Sip or mix. Best Buy. abv: 40% 

Collingwood; $25, 93 points. Noted for an aging process that unusually includes maple wood, this light, easy-sipping whisky is distinctly sweet and mapley on the palate. Bold vanilla and brown sugar flavors are sprinkled with baking spice accents on the drying, lip-smacking finish.. Best Buy. abv: 40% 

Crown Royal Northern Harvest Rye; $30, 91 points. Notably soft and plush, look for pleasing hints of vanilla and marzipan alongside fleeting fresh apple and pineapple notes. It mingles together into an oaky, spicy finish, with clove and cinnamon sparks. Sip or mix. Best Buyabv: 45%

Caribou Crossing Single Barrel; $45, 91 points. Dark honey in the glass, this whisky boasts maple and cedar aromas in the bouquet. Expect lots of spice on the palate, including clove, cinnamon, nutmeg, cayenne and black pepper, all smoothed over by a ribbon of maple and honey. It finishes big, round, buttery and mouthwatering. abv: 40%

Alberta Rye Dark Batch Whisky; $30, 90 points. This Canadian whisky is blended with high-rye Bourbon and a touch of Sherry, yielding a deep amber hue and unusual notes of herbaceous, almost amaro-like sarsaparilla and allspice. The finish shows dark notes of toffee, spicy Mexican chocolate and crème brûlée, plus a brush of alcohol heat. Best Buyabv: 45%

Collectible Canadians

Buy these bottles, if you can get your hands on them. They’re easy to enjoy now, though they are also excellent collectors’ items. If you’re bound for the Great White North, be sure to leave room in your suitcase. These were only released in Canada.

Canadian Club 40 Year Old

This special bottling was released in 2017 to commemorate Canada’s 150th birthday, and it’s the oldest Canadian whisky ever bottled. It’s rich, creamy, flavorful and has plenty of peppery rye and oaky vanilla; only 7,000 bottles were released.

Pike Creek 21 Year Old

Part of the 2017 Northern Border “Rare Release” collection, this 21-year-old Canadian whisky was finished in a Speyside Malt cask. It was an experiment to demonstrate “how whiskies from Scotland and Canada can complement one another to give a smooth and round sipping whisky,” according to the producer.

Published on November 20, 2018
Topics: Drinks
About the Author
Kara Newman 
Spirits Editor

Kara Newman reviews spirits and writes about spirits and cocktail trends for Wine Enthusiast. She's the author of several cocktail books, including Shake.Stir.Sip. and NIGHTCAP: More than 40 Cocktails to Close Out Any Evening, which debuts in September 2018. Email: spirits@wineenthusiast.net




SUBSCRIBE TO
NEWSLETTERS
The latest wine reviews, trends and recipes plus special offers on wine storage and accessories