The Elemental Appeal of Goldschläger, A ’90s Icon

Animation by Eric DeFreitas

When industry veteran Bo Wayne, 54, got his first bartending gig in 1993 at a gay bar in New York City’s East Village, it was “the city of Goldschläger,” he says, referring to the Swiss cinnamon liqueur’s prominence.

“There was a time where we were constantly doing shots of Goldschläger,” he adds, with perhaps a trace of nostalgia.

By the time Wayne left New York City for a decade-long stint in Los Angeles in 1997, Goldschläger was still going strong. And then, suddenly, it vanished.

At least that’s how it seemed to Wayne, who muses about its seeming disappearance in the early 2000s.

“I just thought that it was no longer being made,” he says.

Except, it doesn’t appear there was ever a break in production. (Diageo, the company that owned Goldschläger during this period, didn’t respond to a request for comment.) It seems the public’s thirst for Goldschläger simply waned, as other spirits and cocktail trends gained traction.

Nonetheless, Goldschläger’s reputation looms large in the minds of those who came of age in its heyday.

How Pappy Van Winkle Became a Wildly Expensive, Impossible-to-Find Unicorn

Going for the gold

Los Angeles-based travel, food and drink writer Katherine Alex Beaven, 40, doesn’t recall the very first time she was introduced to Goldschläger, but she remembers being impressed by it in high school.

“We all thought it was extremely fancy because of the gold flecks,” says Beaven.

Brooke Herron, 41, owner of Local Food & Drink, a digital marketing company in Sonoma, also admits she was underage when she first discovered Goldschläger.

“I honestly think it was simply the fact that a bottle on the shelf at the liquor shop had gold flakes in it,” says Herron of the spirit’s appeal. She and her friends would joke that they should “go for the gold.”

Goldschlager
A gold-flecked bottle of Goldschläger / Photo courtesy Goldschläger

Although spirits bottles are often eye-catching, Goldschläger commands attention. The liqueur is packaged in a clear glass bottle with a long neck and a bulbous body. In addition to the gold flakes that float inside the bottle, gold details dominate the packaging, from the gold bottle top to the official-looking round, gold medallion on its front.

In 2018, Sazerac, which owns more than 450 global spirits, added Goldschläger to its portfolio. Asked why the company acquired it, Julia Watson, Sazerac’s brand director says, “For the gold, of course.”

Goldschläger, a German word which “refers to the gold-leaf makers who beat bars of soft gold into wafer-thin sheets,” according to the description on Sazerac’s website, is described as containing “feather-light, palatable gold flakes.”

The liqueur was produced in Switzerland until the 1990s, when it was purchased by Diageo, a British multinational beverage company. Production moved to Italy briefly before it returned to Switzerland. Today, it’s produced in Montreal, says Watson.

Shot in the dark

Raven Adrian, 37, remembers being entranced by Goldschläger’s packaging.

“It was mesmerizing to shake the bottle and watch the pretty flakes,” she says. Plus, it was easy to drink, even though it burned enough to feel “hardcore.”

Seemingly everyone had it in their liquor collection, says Adrian, and it played a prominent role in a seven deadly sins-themed party she hosted for her friend’s 21st birthday some 16 years ago. It involved a game with something called the “penalty of wrath,” where a shot of Goldschläger, Absolut Peppar and a drop of tabasco were offered as punishment.

Adrian hasn’t had Goldschläger since that epic party, she says, but “would love to revisit it as an after-dinner sipper now.”

“We were hardcore. Why waste time chilling it?” —Bo Wayne, bartender

Mike Driscoll, a former social studies teacher, keeps Goldschläger stocked at his bar, Founding Fathers Pub in Buffalo. It hasn’t been a big seller for decades, Driscoll says, but he finds it tasty mixed with an Irish cream liqueur like Baileys.

When Goldschläger ruled the shot scene, Wayne used it to make something called an Oatmeal Cookie. Versions can be found online, but a popular iteration includes Bailey’s Irish Cream, butterscotch schnapps, and, of course, Goldschläger.

On occasion, Wayne also mixed the cinnamon liqueur with cranberry juice or Dr. Pepper.

Ancient goldschlager
The German word “goldschläger” refers to someone who beats gold into thin sheets / Photo by Alamy

Beaven and her friends mostly did shots. They really enjoyed the taste, she says. “Slightly sweet and cinnamon-y with a kick that would light a fire in the back of your throat.”

Herron also recalls the intense cinnamon flavor, but it’s not with any particular fondness. Following one particularly Goldschläger-soaked night, it took years before she could tolerate cinnamon-flavored gum or candy, she says.

These days, cinnamon chewing gum is bearable, but “I still will not touch any cinnamon-flavored alcohol to this day,” says Herron.

Wayne believes that chilling the spirit is a good way to decrease its harsh burn, but that wasn’t a priority for the hard-drinking East Village crew he was serving in the ‘90s.

“We were hardcore,” he says. “Why waste time chilling it?”

Where is it now?

Goldschläger can be found at retailers and restaurants around the country, says Watson. She’s unable to disclose actual sales figures, however.

This is news to Wayne, who says he can’t remember the last time he saw Goldschläger in a bar. After it “disappeared,” people started shooting Jägermeister, says Wayne. He doubts anyone still shoots Goldschläger.

Meme Girls: The Wine Mom Phenomenon Speaks Volumes

In fact, he says that the shots scene, though not obsolete, isn’t what it once was, thanks to a thriving cocktail culture and more options.

Wayne says that people still shoot Jägermeister and other spirits, like Fireball. Neither is on the menu at Spanish Diner, the bar/restaurant on Manhattan’s Far West Side where he tends bar.

Still, Goldschläger is far from extinct. In fact, this March, Sazerac introduced a new iteration, Goldschläger 107. At 107 proof, a nod to the spirit’s original 100-plus proof formula, it seems distinctly hardcore.

Published on June 15, 2021
Topics: Spirits