• 86 Points
    Judd's Hill 1999 Summers Ranch Merlot (Knights Valley)

    Not even in the same ballpark as this winery's excellent Juliana bottling, which costs the same. This is a decent wine, but the flavors have a tobaccoey, dried-herb edge, and the tannins are rustic.

    — S.H. Published 12/1/2003
  • 86 Points
    Judd's Hill 1999 Summers Ranch Merlot (Knights Valley)

    Not even in the same ballpark as this winery's excellent Juliana bottling, which costs the same. This is a decent wine, but the flavors have a tobaccoey, dried-herb edge, and the tannins are rustic.

    — S.H. Published 12/1/2003
  • 86 Points
    Judd's Hill 1999 Summers Ranch Merlot (Knights Valley)

    Not even in the same ballpark as this winery's excellent Juliana bottling, which costs the same. This is a decent wine, but the flavors have a tobaccoey, dried-herb edge, and the tannins are rustic.

    — S.H. Published 12/1/2003
  • 86 Points
    Judd's Hill 1999 Summers Ranch Merlot (Knights Valley)

    Not even in the same ballpark as this winery's excellent Juliana bottling, which costs the same. This is a decent wine, but the flavors have a tobaccoey, dried-herb edge, and the tannins are rustic.

    — S.H. Published 12/1/2003