• 84 Points
    Pierre Amadieu 2003 Domaine Grand Romane Cuvée Prestige (Gigondas)

    Pierre Amadieu's flagship Gigondas is this luxury cuvée from old vines. Yet despite its quality raw materials, I found his 2004 Romane-Machotte more interesting. This bottling features entirely too much cedary, vanilla-laden, barrel-induced seasoning. Sometimes less is more.

    — J.C. Published 11/1/2006
  • 84 Points
    Pierre Amadieu 2003 Domaine Grand Romane Cuvée Prestige (Gigondas)

    Pierre Amadieu's flagship Gigondas is this luxury cuvée from old vines. Yet despite its quality raw materials, I found his 2004 Romane-Machotte more interesting. This bottling features entirely too much cedary, vanilla-laden, barrel-induced seasoning. Sometimes less is more.

    — J.C. Published 11/1/2006
  • 84 Points
    Pierre Amadieu 2003 Domaine Grand Romane Cuvée Prestige (Gigondas)

    Pierre Amadieu's flagship Gigondas is this luxury cuvée from old vines. Yet despite its quality raw materials, I found his 2004 Romane-Machotte more interesting. This bottling features entirely too much cedary, vanilla-laden, barrel-induced seasoning. Sometimes less is more.

    — J.C. Published 11/1/2006
  • 84 Points
    Pierre Amadieu 2003 Domaine Grand Romane Cuvée Prestige (Gigondas)

    Pierre Amadieu's flagship Gigondas is this luxury cuvée from old vines. Yet despite its quality raw materials, I found his 2004 Romane-Machotte more interesting. This bottling features entirely too much cedary, vanilla-laden, barrel-induced seasoning. Sometimes less is more.

    — J.C. Published 11/1/2006