Collectors will be interested to learn how this bottling compares to Talley's Rincon Pinot. The Rincon is the more immediately likeable. Rosemary's shares the same notes of gorgeous Pinot character, but is more tannic. That doesn't mean it's not fabulous now. Dry and tart, with an earthiness to the cherry flavors, it's a big thumbs up. Drink now through 2006.